Indecisive me - HELP!

Okay, so here's the deal. Lou got me two purses for Christmas. He couldn't decide which one I'd like better, so he just gave them both to me and told me to keep the one I liked best. If only I wasn't horrible at choosing between two good things. These purses are so different from one another, and that's one of the things that makes it so hard. One is a cute satchel-style handbag, and the other is a basic over-the-shoulder hobo bag. I am so indecisive when it comes to trivial decisions like this, so I'm asking my friends out there which one they think is better (those of you who haven't by now rolled your eyes at this post and gone on to the next blog). I am not writing the prices because this is a gift, so I am not using that as a factor (not to mention I don't know how much they cost because Lou didn't tell me). And NO, I am NOT keeping them both, so don't suggest that

Satchel handbag

(I have such small arms, I can actually wear this on my shoulder too, but having two thick leather straps there is not really as comfy as a regular over the shoulder bag)

Pros:

-cute and stylish (I love the retro big zippers and the color of the leather)

-lots of compartments for better organization

-no bigger footprint than my old one

-pretty royal purple satin ( though probably faux satin) lining

Cons:

-HEAVY!!! This purse weighs 4 lbs 5 oz when it has all my stuff in it! It weighs over 2 lbs when it is empty! I am wondering if it would be really annoying to carry around a purse this heavy all the time

-I am wondering if this is going to be dirty looking fast with such light-colored leather

-smooth leather. This part I actually like - it makes for a more polished look, but of course it scratches easily, and having three kids, I have to take this into account. Ditto about the "getting dirty" worry

front

side (you can see the retro-style large zippers here)

back of purse (that is actually a pocket you are seeing there)

Hobo over-the-shoulder bag

Pros:

-this purse is about 20% bigger, which means not only does all my stuff fit with no problem, but I can put more stuff in it if I want to down the road

-It has plenty of compartments to organize my stuff (not as many as the satchel, but it's enough for my use)

-It is not too heavy. It weighs about 3 1/2 pounds when full of my stuff (about 1 1/2 pounds empty)

-the dark color will hide the wear and tear better

-the soft hammered leather will not scratch as easily

Cons:

-it's a good bit bigger than the other purse. Why do I put this as both a pro AND a con? Being able to fit more stuff in your purse (thus making it even heavier) is not necessarily a good thing...

-the lining is not as pretty - some sort of microfiber (but then again, it's probably more durable than the satin)

-it's kind of boring and whatever. Just sort of your basic purse (but then again, at this stage in my life, should I stick with that? I don't know.)

So, what do you think?